Amegadjie is a tackle for me. I think he's a fine target if we stay put. That guy has arm length for days but injured so no testing. From what little I've seen he seems very athletic. Jump in competition is concerning.
Personally I'd like a more athletic tackle so I'd go:
Suamataia
Amegadjie
Rosengarten (if we're ok with 33.5 arms)
Paul
The rest
I could be convinced to swap Rosengarten up a spot just based on level of competition