Jump to content

Position-by-position grades for the 2014 season


Recommended Posts

 
 

This is what I was looking for earlier.   Basically the grades are like this:

 

Quarterback:   CPlus

Runningback   A minus

Wide Receivers    D minus

Offensive Line    D

Tight End    B minus

Defensive Line    B minus

Outside Linebackers   A

Inside Linebackers  D

Defensive Backfield  Outside:    B

Defensive Backfield  Inside:  B minus

Special Teams   B minus

Coaching:   B plus

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

This is what I was looking for earlier. Basically the grades are like this:

 

Quarterback: CPlus

Runningback A minus

Wide Receivers D minus

Offensive Line D

Tight End B minus

Defensive Line B minus

Outside Linebackers A

Inside Linebackers D

Defensive Backfield Outside: B

Defensive Backfield Inside: B minus

Special Teams B minus

Coaching: B plus

Secondary has to be an A

Sorry

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Guest Tomahawk hop

Secondary has to be an A

Sorry

I disagree. They were very good, but A grades should be reserved for impact players that make game changing plays. The defensive backfield was woefully short at creating turnovers. For that reason alone I could not give them an A rating.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I disagree. They were very good, but A grades should be reserved for impact players that make game changing plays. The defensive backfield was woefully short at creating turnovers. For that reason alone I could not give them an A rating.

And they didn't give up a 300 yard passing game all year with minimal turnovers in a passing league. Rivers twice, manning twice, Brady, Big Ben,.... We also boasted the number 1 red zone defense in football as well as no 30 point games. Sean smith was a star and so was Abdullah. Don't need turnovers to see that.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I can't agree with this. This unit arguably didn't meet the qualifications for a C: It gave up two game-changing fake punt conversions for a first down, gave away an additional first down conversion on a penalty, and hit on less than 80% of field goal attempts inside 40 yards (although hitting 80% on field goal attempts at 50 or more yards out was nice). A punt return and a kick return that each scored six points represented a measurable amount of good that far from outweighed the special teams' deficiencies.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

And they didn't give up a 300 yard passing game all year with minimal turnovers in a passing league. Rivers twice, manning twice, Brady, Big Ben,.... We also boasted the number 1 red zone defense in football as well as no 30 point games. Sean smith was a star and so was Abdullah. Don't need turnovers to see that.

It's subjective.  I thought they were very good as a unit, and Smith shined, but this team very much needed turnovers to help them win games and the defensive back-field produced very little.  Furthermore, they were part of a defensive unit that, as a whole, gave up more yards per rush attempt than all but two other teams in the league.  In my book that effort does not get a grade of "A".  At any rate, it's certainly well down the list of areas in need of upgrade.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
 

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
  • Create New...